L'arte della gioia

HT Film

Drama
Italian     7.5     2024     Italy

Overview

Born on the 1st of January 1900 in a poor family in rural Sicily, Modesta pursues happiness since her childhood without falling victim to the constraints of society. After a tragic event that takes her away from her family, Modesta is welcomed into a monastery, where she becomes the Mother Superior’s protégé thanks to her intelligence and stubbornness. Later, she arrives at the villa belonging to the Princess of Brandiforti, where she makes herself indispensable. This relentless process of emancipation goes along with a journey of personal growth and sexual awakening, which lead her to discover and claim the right to pleasure and happiness.

Reviews

druscilla_of_old wrote:
What a disappointment. If you aren't a creepy wealthy old White man, this show has nothing to offer you, I promise. Move on. This series had the potential to become Italy's own TV masterpiece in the vein of Aisling Walsh's Fingersmith (2005) but its thinly-veiled attempts at pleasing creepy White men's questionable sexual proclivities decidedly reduced it to nothing more than a sexually titillating curiosity for such men. I went into it expecting a complex story of female empowerment that treats women, especially queer women, and their relationships as much more than queerbaiting devices and objects for the abusive consumption of male characters and audiences. How disappointed I was. Not only is the primary queer relationship in the series treated as nothing more than a casual fling that the protagonist, Modesta (played by Tecla Insolia), uses whenever and however it suits her, but it is men - much older men, to be accurate - who are given the ultimate control and power over the protagonist and other women. For instance, while, early on, Modesta professes to love Beatrice (Alma Noce), it is later on made more than amply clear to the viewer that Modesta's love and heart belong only to Carmine (Guido Caprino), a man old enough to be her father and who is, in fact, Beatrice's father. Moreover, Modesta's ultimate "win" in the series is predicated entirely on the "good will" and power of Carmine, and not to any of the meticulous planning and efforts that she put in towards the same end. These facts alone betray this show's pandering to the patriarchal status quo that, no doubt, many of its creators exist within and are committed to upholding. Like, I'm sorry but a series which ends with the female protagonist being literally handed her "win" by a creepy old man that reminds her of her pedophilic father but who she nevertheless somehow(???) loves is not the female empowerment story that Valeria Golina (writer-director) et al. marketed it as. And I've not even talked about how incredibly creepy the opening episode is, what with all the gratuitous nudity and overt sexualization of a literal child. The only things that made me grant this series a rating of 6 include its incredible cinematography and the outstanding performances by Tecla Insonia (as Modesta) and Viviana Mocciaro (as young Modesta). Valeria Golina and Tecla Insonia's offscreen pro-Palestine activism also made me a bit partial to the series. Other than these, there are no other reasons to dedicate one's time to this show.

Similar